2011 Graeme Clark Oration Questions
Professor Sejnowski kindly agreed to answer questions posted on the Graeme Clark Oration website for a week following the Oration. Below are some questions received and Professor Sejnowski’s responses.
Name: Andre Peterson
What is your neurophilosophy? your epistemology on consciousness? i.e. You wrote a book with P. Churchland, are you an eliminative materialist, reductionist, physicalist, dualist etc ThankyouName: Dan Witton
I was most interested about the idea of running chips in analogue mode at low power rates and wondered whether what you were saying was whether they could be used with micro voltages in the same way that you were measuring action potentials in nerves. ( I loved that metaphor). In that way would it be possible to increase the amount of triggers by measuring activity at specific voltages? I would wonder whether there was an analogy here between amplitude modulation and frequency modulation in radio waves.Name: John
1. How do you train a Hopfield ANN ? 2. Can Hopfield ANN’s contextualize inputs i.e. does it have memory ? 3. Can a Hopfield ANN be analyzed in the same way as a multi-state filter ? 4. What sort of ANNs did you use to separate the voice and music ? (ANN = Artificial Neural Net)Name: John Wells
I hoped to hear more about "brain behaviour in disorders such as autism and schizophrenia" which were advertised as being included in the oration. I guess this is more a comment than a question as I am not likely to be able to hear the topics which were apparently left out of the lecture.For a review paper look up "Sejnowski Behrens" in PubMed: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?term=sejnowski%20behrens
Name: Karen Johns
As I am in education, I was interested in hearing about how the brain behaves in such disorders as autism - as time got away from us at the Oration and you were unable to address this component. Could you please offer ‘some’ information on this area of brain function in this condition. Thank you KarenCourchesne E, Pierce K, Schumann CM, Redcay E, Buckwalter JA, Kennedy DP, Morgan J., Mapping early brain development in autism, Neuron. 2007 Oct 25;56(2):399-413
Name: Kaye Mullins
What processes/courses would an undergraduate Psychology student need to go through in order to become involved in the development of technologies you spoke about? Is it possible?Meltzoff, A. N., Kuhl, P. K., Movellan, J., Sejnowski, T. J., Foundations for a new science of learning, Science 325: 284-288 (2009).
Name: Tim Josling
My question is about the statement early on that the brain consists of many specialized components. Undoubtedly true overall, but... Looking at the neocortex which seems to be very central to what we think of as intelligence, however, it seems to be very uniform in structure and it seems to perform very similar algorithms in seemingly very different domains. One example of this is the success in getting the auditory part of a ferret’s brain to "see". Similar experiments with using the human tongue to "see: (placing a mat of pins onto the tongue as a way to get visual data into the brains of blind people). What are your thoughts on the idea of Jeff Hawkins that the neocortex employs a single algorithm? Do you think Hawkins is on the right track with his theory of Hierarchical Temporal memory as a model for the Neocortex?Name: Tom Hatcher
According to some extrapolations of Moore’s law, in the next 20 years the power of the biggest supercomputers will rival the human brain. Do you think that the first human brain simulations will be run on these machines, or a new class of massively parallel hardware? When it becomes possible to code artificial neurons that replicate the functionality of cortical neurons, and when a suitable interface between the two can be found, do you think it may be possible to upload your consciousness into the machine, initially just as an appendage to the original brain, but then eventually discarding the biological infrastructure altogether?Name: Paul Tune
Thank you for the fascinating talk! I am a researcher myself and am looking for a way to get into the study of artificial neural networks. In one of your slides, you mentioned something about a neural network with added noise and a sleep mode. This also apparently has some relation to sleep and human brain plasticity. I have two questions. What do you mean by "noise"? Is it just arbitrary input? Have you tried specially selected (possibly adversarial) input? Has there been work done to compare the competitiveness of neural networks in signal processing compared to recent advancements (for e.g. compressive sensing) of algorithms?Artificial neural networks are most efficient when the inputs produce a pattern of neural activity that is sparse, that is, only a few of the many neurons are active. A new generation of artificial neural network models are being developed that take this one step further and uses random sparse projections of the inputs based on compressed sensing.
Name: Kaelasha Tyler
My image of neurons and dendrites tends to be a static one, based as it is on text book pictures of Golgi stains in vitro. However we know that living neurons and dendrites do physically move. I have heard the movement of a mass of neurons described as ’wriggling’. My question: do living neurons wriggle? I guess that amounts to the question of, how much and how fast is the physical movement of neurons and dendrites, for example, as they find and make new synaptic connections? Maybe you have had to include this sort of information in a computational model, and if so, I would love to know- do living neurons really wriggle? Cheers, Kaelasha.Name: John Zubevich
Why did you suggest that 2000–2050 would be the era of information when what is really necessary is analysis and comprehension of much of the information we have but which is only used if it is considered commercially expliotable because the information can be used as raw data to argue a particular point which would not be tentable if properly analysed? e.g. many scientific pieces of information like the cane toad in Queensland – truly a disaster that was not well thought out.Name: Rachel DeSumma
I would like to know more about findings of brain differences in individuals with Aspergers syndrome and autism and what this means for treatment approaches. Thank you.Here is a source of more information at NIH:
http://www.nichd.nih.gov/publications/pubs/sos_autism/sub6.cfm
Name: Andrew Hill
Prof Sejnowski, early in your oration you said, "The brain does not work without the body". Do you think that the brain also needs an environment beyond the body in order to function? If so, what kinds of research do you think would best reveal that relationship?Name: Andreas Hendarto
My question is on neuromorphic engineering. How long would you project it to be before a complete set of networks (which you presented) could be compiled to create a fully-functioning animal-like ’brain’? And do you believe such a brain, if advanced enough, would be able to eventually pass the Turing test and yet still retain the superior logical deductions of today’s conventional computers? Thank you so much for your thought-provoking oration!Download flyer
Click here to download the Graeme Clark Oration 2012 flyer for friends/classmates
Oration highlights
The Oration informs the community about advances where biology, computing and engineering come together.
Click here to view information about previous Orations:
About Linda Partridge
The Royal Society Interview on The New Science of Ageing
The Science of Ageing - Royal Society Publishing
The Royal Society 2009 Croonian Lecture, The New Biology of Ageing